The Ultimate Local Foodie Guide: 10 Must-Try Dishes in Cleveland

The Ultimate Local Foodie Guide: 10 Must-Try Dishes in Cleveland, Ohio

Cleveland, Ohio, isn’t just a city by the shores of Lake Erie — it’s a vibrant culinary destination where rich cultural heritage meets bold innovation. From family-owned diners to trendy eateries, Cleveland boasts an array of dishes that highlight its diverse food scene. Whether you’re a local wanting to shake up your regular dining spots or a visitor eager to taste authentic flavours, this guide will lead you through 10 must-try dishes in Cleveland that truly define the city’s gastronomic identity.

Own a restaurant in Cleveland? Get your business noticed by listing your spot on our local directory, the go-to platform for food lovers and locals hunting for the best eats.

1. Polish Boy Sandwich — Seti’s Polish Boys

If Cleveland had a culinary mascot, it would be the Polish Boy: a deliciously messy, flavour-packed sandwich combining juicy kielbasa, crispy golden fries, crunchy tangy coleslaw, and smoky BBQ sauce, all wrapped in a soft bun. Seti’s iconic food truck is THE place to experience this local legend, loved for its authentic taste and the lively street food vibe.

2. Pierogies — Sokolowski’s University Inn

A nod to Cleveland’s strong Eastern European roots, pierogies are the ultimate comfort food—soft dumplings generously filled with potato, cheese, sauerkraut, or sometimes meat. At Sokolowski’s University Inn, a family-run institution since 1923, these classic pierogies are cooked to perfection, evoking the nostalgic warmth of grandma’s kitchen.

3. Lake Erie Walleye — Pier W

When you’re on the shores of Lake Erie, you simply can’t miss sampling its prized catch: walleye. Pier W elevates this regional favourite with fresh preparations paired with breathtaking waterfront views. The atmosphere perfectly complements the delicate, flaky fish—making it an ideal spot for a special dinner or celebration.

4. Corned Beef Sandwich — Slyman’s Deli

Known nationwide, Slyman’s Deli serves what many consider the best corned beef sandwich in the country. Towering piles of tender, juicy, perfectly seasoned corned beef on rye bread guarantee a hearty, satisfying meal, deeply woven into Cleveland’s culinary culture.

5. Mac & Cheese — Mabel’s BBQ

Celebrity chef Michael Symon’s Mabel’s BBQ features a mac & cheese side that’s a cult favourite. Creamy and velvety with a smoky undertone and a golden crisp top, it pairs flawlessly with their succulent brisket and ribs, perfect for comfort food lovers craving a rich, savoury experience.

6. Pho — Superior Pho

When Cleveland locals crave authentic Vietnamese cuisine, Superior Pho is their go-to spot. The pho broth is gently simmered for hours, developing a complex depth of flavour that blends beautifully with fresh herbs, tender cuts of meat, and silky rice noodles. It’s a soul-warming choice, especially during chilly Cleveland days.

7. Chicken Paprikash — Balaton Restaurant

Celebrating Cleveland’s Hungarian heritage, the hearty chicken paprikash at Balaton Restaurant is a beloved dish. Tender chicken simmered in a creamy, paprika-spiced sauce and served over fluffy dumplings delivers a satisfying meal that’s both comforting and richly flavorful.

8. Tacos — Barrio Tacos

For a fun, casual dining experience, Barrio Tacos brings vibrant flavours to the table with customizable tacos. Fresh, creative ingredients and house-made sauces allow every guest to build the perfect taco, making it a hotspot for casual date nights or late-night cravings.

9. Vegan Comfort Food — Cleveland Vegan

Cleveland’s plant-based food scene is thriving, and Cleveland Vegan stands out with inventive dishes like spicy buffalo tofu wraps, creamy vegan mac & cheese, and decadent baked goods. This spot proves that vegan food can be hearty, delicious, and satisfying for all eaters.

10. Doughnuts — Brewnuts

Merging two favourites, craft beer and doughnuts—Brewnuts concocts truly unique flavours like maple bacon bourbon and stout chocolate glaze. Their inventive, Instagram-worthy creations delight local sweet tooths and visitors alike, looking for a fun twist on dessert.

Where to Find These Local Gems

The heartbeat of Cleveland’s food scene lies in its passionate chefs and family businesses; each dish tells a piece of the city’s story. Exploring these iconic meals not only supports local businesses but also connects you to Cleveland’s rich cultural tapestry. Whether you’re aiming to try something new or share your foodie adventures, these must-try dishes offer a genuine taste of Cleveland.

Frequently Asked Questions About Cleveland’s Food Scene

1. What foods is Cleveland known for?
Cleveland is famous for its hearty, comfort-driven dishes reflecting its Eastern European heritage and diverse culinary influences. Signature foods include the Polish Boy sandwich, pierogies, walleye from Lake Erie, and classic deli sandwiches like corned beef.

2. Where do locals eat in Cleveland?
Locals enjoy a mix of historic spots like Sokolowski’s University Inn and Slyman’s Deli, as well as newer, popular places like Mabel’s BBQ and Barrio Tacos, especially in vibrant neighbourhoods like Ohio City and Tremont.

3. What’s the best way to experience Cleveland’s food culture?
Start by exploring Cleveland’s eclectic neighbourhoods and trying iconic dishes that showcase the city’s mix of old-world traditions and modern flavours. Food festivals, farmers' markets, and food tours also offer immersive experiences.

4. Are there vegan-friendly restaurants in Cleveland?
Yes! Cleveland has an expanding plant-based scene, with places like Cleveland Vegan offering inventive vegan comfort food that appeals even to non-vegans.

5. Can I find authentic ethnic foods in Cleveland?
Absolutely. Cleveland’s food landscape reflects its immigrant communities, with excellent Hungarian, Polish, Vietnamese, and other authentic ethnic eateries throughout the city.

Ready to get your restaurant featured?

If you’re a local Ohio food business owner, join Localeadr to put your restaurant on the map and reach hungry customers fast.